Haven’t we been here before?
There’s something rather familiar about Milburn’s argument, and it takes me back to Iain Duncan Smith and the original ambitions behind Universal Credit. Whatever your political views of IDS, the fundamental principle was straightforward: work should pay. People should be financially better off taking employment, even for relatively few hours, and better off again as they increased their earnings. The objective wasn’t simply to reduce the benefits bill, but to create a system that encouraged people to move towards financial independence rather than trapping them in a situation where taking employment could leave them little better off.
Unfortunately, the Treasury subsequently reduced the generosity of Universal Credit’s work allowances as part of George Osborne’s austerity drive in 2015. These changes meant that many claimants would begin losing benefits at lower earnings levels than originally envisaged, weakening an important element of the original incentive to work. The Institute for Fiscal Studies examined the consequences of these changes at the time. I’ve generally had considerable respect for Osborne’s approach to economic management, but I think this was a significant mistake. It illustrates a recurring problem with how governments approach long-term reform. The Treasury understandably wants to balance the books today, while the financial and social benefits of helping someone build a sustainable working life may take years to materialise.
And that’s precisely the challenge Milburn is confronting now. His proposals envisage substantial investment in employment support, recognising that the returns may take a decade to materialise. That isn’t an easy proposition for a Chancellor facing immediate spending pressures, but the alternative is to continue spending vast sums managing the consequences of economic inactivity rather than addressing its causes. We need to start thinking about welfare reform as an investment in Britain’s future productive capacity, rather than simply another opportunity to reduce expenditure in the next financial year.
Making work pay isn’t a left-wing idea or a right-wing idea. It’s common sense.
But where are the jobs coming from?
Milburn’s proposals include the idea of guaranteeing young people opportunities for employment or training and reducing the cost of employing younger workers. These are interesting proposals, but they raise an obvious question. Who is actually going to employ them? Businesses don’t create jobs simply because a government announces an employment target. They recruit when they have the demand, confidence and financial capacity to do so, and right now many employers are facing considerable pressure.
The increase in employers’ National Insurance contributions introduced in April 2025 added significantly to employment costs for many businesses, particularly those employing substantial numbers of lower-paid workers. I wrote about the likely consequences of these changes back in November 2024 , when the measures were first announced, questioning how increasing the cost of employment could possibly be consistent with a strategy for economic growth. Those concerns weren’t confined to business owners. The Office for Budget Responsibility forecast that the increase would reduce labour supply by the equivalent of 50,000 full-time workers, while also placing downward pressure on wages and increasing costs for employers. Although the increased Employment Allowance protected some smaller businesses, many others have faced additional costs at precisely the time when confidence and economic growth have been weak.
There’s therefore a certain irony in Milburn proposing reductions in employers’ National Insurance for younger workers to stimulate recruitment, when the Government increased employment costs more broadly only last year. I listened to Milburn being challenged on this very point during his interview with Stig Abell on Times Radio. He was reluctant to describe Rachel Reeves’ National Insurance increases as a mistake, but his proposals nevertheless recognise that reducing the cost of employing people can encourage businesses to create opportunities. That doesn’t mean National Insurance alone is responsible for the challenges facing the labour market, but it does raise legitimate questions about the consistency of government policy. We cannot expect employers to generate jobs without considering the commercial realities they face, particularly when smaller businesses often have less capacity to absorb additional employment costs.
Getting Britain working means more than getting people off benefits
After nearly 30 years working in recruitment and HR, I’ve learned that employment isn’t always a straightforward transition from unemployment to a permanent, full-time job. For someone who has been economically inactive for a considerable period, even a few days of temporary employment can be enormously valuable. It can rebuild confidence, provide recent work experience, develop skills and, importantly, remind someone that they have something worthwhile to contribute. Indeed, Milburn himself has suggested that working just a few hours a week could represent meaningful progress for a young person who isn’t currently working.
But there’s a problem that we encounter regularly in our own recruitment business. People are sometimes reluctant to accept temporary assignments because they’re frightened of what might happen to their benefits. They might be offered a week’s work, perhaps with the possibility of something longer, but worry that accepting it could disrupt their financial support and leave them worse off when the assignment ends. When someone is already struggling financially, that uncertainty can be enough to discourage them from taking the opportunity. Universal Credit was intended to accommodate changing earnings and movement into employment, yet the practical experience of some people considering short-term work suggests that we still have more to do.
This is where I believe temporary employment could play a much greater role in getting Britain working. A short assignment can be the first step towards something longer, providing an opportunity for someone to rebuild their employment history without immediately committing to a permanent position. But for that to work effectively, we need a benefits system that genuinely accommodates people moving in and out of short-term employment, without creating unnecessary financial uncertainty or administrative complications. We should be encouraging people to take those first steps, not leaving them frightened of the financial consequences of trying.
And surely, in 2026, the technology exists to make this possible? Employers already report earnings directly to HMRC through Real Time Information (RTI), and the DWP already uses that information to calculate Universal Credit payments. The data is already there, so why aren’t we using it to create a genuinely responsive, app-based benefits system that automatically adjusts financial support as people move in and out of temporary employment? Someone should be able to accept a week’s work, earn some money and return to benefits when the assignment ends, without worrying about delays, administrative complications or being left without an income. There are undoubtedly practical challenges to overcome, particularly around payment dates and assessment periods, but surely these aren’t beyond our technological capabilities? Then again, having recently written about the DWP’s apparent reliance on carrier pigeons , perhaps I’m being a little optimistic!
There’s also an opportunity here that I hope won’t be overlooked. Britain already has an established recruitment industry, including thousands of independent agencies working closely with employers in their local communities. These businesses understand their local labour markets, know where vacancies exist and have the infrastructure and experience to arrange temporary assignments, manage payroll and support workers through their placements. If the Government is serious about investing billions in helping people into employment, surely it should explore how that existing expertise can contribute.
And I don’t mean simply awarding enormous national contracts to a handful of major recruitment companies. There’s a genuine opportunity to develop programmes that actively engage smaller, independent recruitment businesses, helping people into employment while supporting the growth of the very businesses that contribute so much to our local economies. A nationally supported programme, delivered through local employers and recruitment specialists, could be an important part of the answer. It’s an idea I’ll be exploring in considerably more detail in a future article.
Ultimately, this debate shouldn’t simply be about reducing the number of people claiming benefits. It should be about creating a stronger, more productive economy in which more people have the opportunity to contribute, earn a living, develop their skills and build financially independent lives. More people in sustainable employment means more economic activity, greater tax revenues and potentially less pressure on the welfare system. But it also means greater confidence, independence and opportunity for the individuals concerned.
Milburn’s review raises some important questions, and I welcome the renewed attention being given to a problem that has been developing for far too long. The challenge now is turning ambitious proposals into practical solutions that work for jobseekers, employers and the wider economy. Over the coming weeks, I’ll be exploring some of those questions in more detail, particularly the role of temporary employment, the importance of making work financially worthwhile and the contribution Britain’s independent recruitment agencies could make.
Because getting Britain working isn’t about left or right. It’s about common sense, sound economics and giving people the opportunity to build better lives.
Jason Perry FCIPD
Managing Director, ASL Recruitment Ltd
Alan Milburn. Official portrait, licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.



